Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors

www.marktreichel.com

https://www.linkedin.com/in/mark-treichel/

Mark Treichel recorded this episode after presenting to a credit union supervisory committee on the 5300 and the call report — why it matters to NCUA, and why it should matter to you. The first half is the risk view from NCUA’s side of the table. The second half is what the rules actually ask of the supervisory committee.

NCUA collects and analyzes call report information to assess a credit union’s financial condition and evaluate existing and potential risks to the National Credit Union Share Insurance Fund. Its risk-focused exam program relies heavily on the accuracy of that data, and inaccurate information impairs an examiner’s ability to properly identify and assess risk. With the agency down 27% of staff, good data is what lets NCUA decide where to send people.

Mark’s read on direction — stated as his opinion — is data-driven supervision. The proposed strategic plan commits to more closely integrating advanced analytics and enhanced decision-making support tools into examination scoping, scheduling, and CAMELS rating processes, under strategic objective 1.3. The 2024 annual report says that by analyzing much of a credit union’s financial and operational condition remotely, it may be possible to reduce the frequency and scope of on-site examinations. He traces the virtual exam idea back to Mark McWatters’ time on the board and Larry Fazio’s budget work at Examination and Insurance, and notes a rumor — he emphasizes that it is a rumor — that NCUA may be redoing MERIT or adding functions to it.

Then the six reasons the 5300 carries weight: it is NCUA’s primary lens between exams, it sets your capital classification and prompt corrective action, it is a legal filing an officer declares true and correct, it is a public document anyone can pull, it drives the 1% NCUSIF deposit and the equity ratio that decides whether NCUA charges a premium, and it works as a proxy for whether your internal controls function.

The supervisory committee half turns on one word. The rule’s verb is ensure, not prepare. Management prepares the call report; the committee ensures the credit union meets measurement and filing requirements and that reports are promptly prepared and accurate. The committee owns the auditor relationship, and total assets on the year-end call report determine which annual audit the credit union must obtain. Mark walks through internal audit as the committee’s engine, where the committee adds value versus what belongs to management, NCUA’s recommended practices from the Examiner’s Guide — noting that a guide is not a regulation — and closes with five questions a committee can put to management every quarter.

NCUA uses your call report to scope exams, time them, and feed your rating — and with the agency down 27% of staff, that data carries more weight than it used to. Mark Treichel covers the six reasons the 5300 matters, what the supervisory committee rule actually requires (ensure, not prepare), and five questions to put to management every quarter.